LucyLee - IKWYM. You gave it a try and found out it didn't work for you. Give yourself plenty of grace. You are analyzing and fine-tuning your system. A couple of times a year I find myself looking at other systems and admiring how it is working for someone else. Only by trying and failing at imitating them that I learned it doesn't work for me.
DD9 didn't finish school until a few minutes before 5pm. DS12 finished around 3pm. Thankfully school went smoothly this afternoon. The struggles we had this morning has opened up more communication. We are still talking about what each of us could have done chosen to do differently.
I did something this morning that I'm not sure was a good idea because I don't remember ever using it before. It was done in a moment of frustration. I needed a consequence that would get their attention and this did. I told the kids if they didn't stop their behavior that I would put something of theirs into time-out for the rest of the day. This resulted in me putting one of DD9 beanie-boos in timeout. I also put DS12 backpack (which contains Bluetooth speaker) in timeout. The timeout place is a shelf in the schoolroom They can see their possessions and they know they are okay. They can retrieve their possession after sunrise tomorrow. I wouldn't be surprised if they are up early tomorrow to retrieve their item from timeout. Choices have consequences. This was an extremely easy consequence for me to do. I'm trying to figure out if it has a negative side to it. Where did I leave that child-rearing instruction manual?